Related Topics
Investing , Stocks

Corporate Investors Are Awful Market Timers – Here’s Why

U.S. corporate buybacks on pace to set record -- what that means

by Bob Stokes
Updated: November 14, 2018

Corporate insiders do not have a good track record of timing the market.

As examples, their share buybacks reached record highs in the stock market peak years of 2000 and 2007.

A classic Elliott Wave Theorist provided insight:

It may seem that "inside information" should give company managers an advantage in deciding when to engage in buybacks of their own company's stock. On the contrary, their misperceptions are the same as everyone else's. When the market goes up for a long time, corporate health factors strengthen, and when it goes down, they weaken. Insiders misinterpret these indications of their own company's present health as being the same as its prospects.

Yes, those who hold lofty positions within some of the nation's biggest companies are just as much a part of the investing "crowd" as Main Street retail investors.

Robert Prechter's 2017 book, The Socionomic Theory of Finance, showed a chart which provides historical evidence. He says:


As the chart shows, corporations buy back lots of stock near market tops and very little near market bottoms....

Corporations have lost 126 billion dollars investing in their own shares just from 2013 through 2015, even though the stock market was rising almost the whole time!... These outsized losses are due primarily to two types of herding: on a company-by-company basis and on a timing basis.

Considering the track record of corporate buybacks, look at this Nov. 8 news item from CNBC:

Companies are buying back stock at a record pace this month

The stock market's biggest buying force is on track to post a historic November as corporations resume a rapid pace of share buybacks....

As you might imagine, EWI's analysts are also keeping tabs on other stock market indicators. Every one of them is revealing in its own way.

Yet, none are substitutes for knowing the precise juncture of the market's Elliott wave pattern.

As Frost & Prechter's Elliott Wave Principle points out:

The Wave Principle often indicates in advance the relative magnitude of the next period of market progress or regress.

Look below to learn how you can tap into our latest insights about the market's next big move.

Pay Attention to the Stock Market's NEXT WAVE

You may know that the stock market unfolds in fives waves in the direction of the main trend. Countertrend moves unfold in three waves.

Each of these eight waves has its own "personality."

EWI's Financial Forecast Service describes the "characteristics" of what we anticipate to be the market's next major wave.

Get our timely insights, risk-free. Details are below …

Here's How Your Financial Forecast Service Team Works to Prepare YOU For New Opportunities

Read This, And Then Let Us Show You FFS in Action, 100% Risk-Free

Your Financial Forecast Service team includes three of the best-known market analysts in the world – Robert Prechter, Steven Hochberg and Pete Kendall. If you are familiar with Elliott wave analysis, you know exactly who they are.

No other analysts in the world, anywhere, undertake the depth of research that goes into the Financial Forecast Service. Throughout the month, Bob, Steve and Pete sift through mountains of data, often studying 100 years of data or more. Why? Because a chart of the big, long term waves is the only way to know precisely where in the pattern we are today – and therefore, precisely where we are most likely to go next.

Here's what you get with the Financial Forecast Service, 100% Risk-Free for 30 days

Every Month

At the end of each month, your team of analysts gets together and lets the sparks fly. The result? The Elliott Wave Financial Forecast. It's just one of three essential parts of your Financial Forecast Service. When you get a new issue, you can be sure it contains the most critical information you must know about the markets this month.

Three Days Per Week

In addition, at the end of the U.S. trading session every Monday, Wednesday and Friday, your team updates its monthly analysis with the Short Term Update. In STU, they prepare you for the most likely price moves in the next 3-5 trading days.

Latest Research

Finally, once every month, Robert Prechter sends you his very latest research about Elliott waves in the markets and society. For 30+ years, The Elliott Wave Theorist has delivered more groundbreaking market research than any other publication on the planet. One month Bob might prepare you for a multi-year move in a market; the next he will deliver a jaw-dropping study that challenges everything you thought you knew about investing. Whatever he writes, it will help you hone your grasp of the psychology behind the markets – and give you an enormous advantage over other investors.

Prepare for Risks and Opportunities That Will Surprise Most Investors

See our eye-opening forecasts for stocks, bonds, gold, USD and more.

Risk-Free, Start Your Subscription Now


for 1 month of unparalleled market insights